Brand vs brand
Hill's Science Diet vs Rachael Ray Nutrish
Same rubric. Same nine components. Same flagged-ingredient list. Just the data.
B
Hill's Science Diet
64.2
Avg score
98
Products
0
Recalls
Top-rated
Hill's Science Diet Adult Small Breed & Mini Breed Chicken & Beef Variety Pack Wet Dog Food, 5.8-oz can, case of 12
80/100
C
Rachael Ray Nutrish
57.8
Avg score
37
Products
0
Recalls
Top-rated
Rachael Ray Nutrish Real Salmon, Veggies & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Dog Food, 12-lb bag
73/100
Side by side
Metric
Hill's Science Diet
Rachael Ray Nutrish
Average score
64.2
57.8
Median score
66
59
Products scored
98
37
A-tier products
3
0
F-tier products
0
0
% with flagged ingredient
74%
100%
Recall history
0
0
Median price/lb
$3.47
$1.61
Green highlight indicates the better value for that metric.
Top 3 from Hill's Science Diet
Hill's Science Diet
Hill's Science Diet Adult Small Breed & Mini Breed Chicken & Beef Variety Pack Wet Dog Food, 5.8-oz can, case of 12
$29.88wetFair
80
Hill's Science Diet
Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Digestion Small Breed & Mini Breed Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food, 12-lb bag
$5.25/lbdryFair
77
Hill's Science Diet
Hill's Science Diet Puppy Sensitive Stomach & Sensitive Skin Salmon & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food, 13-lb bag
$4.85/lbdryFair
76
Top 3 from Rachael Ray Nutrish
Rachael Ray Nutrish
Rachael Ray Nutrish Real Salmon, Veggies & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Dog Food, 12-lb bag
$1.66/lbdryFair
73
Rachael Ray Nutrish
Rachael Ray Nutrish Real Beef, Pea & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Dog Food, 13-lb bag
$1.54/lbdryFair
69
Rachael Ray Nutrish
Rachael Ray Nutrish Healthy Weight Food Real Turkey, Brown Rice & Venison Recipe Adult Dry Dog Food, 12-lb bag
$1.75/lbdryFair
64
How this comparison was generated
Both brands graded the same way. Always.
Same rubric, same nine components, same flagged ingredient list. No special treatment.
Read the methodology